10 Italian Restaurants In New York That Have the Best Dishes


  • L’Artusi in the West Village offers modern Italian cuisine in a comfortable setting, featuring handmade pasta and an extensive wine selection.
  • Via Carota is a charming rustic trattoria in the West Village known for its authentic Italian flavors and romantic dining spaces.
  • Babbo in Greenwich Village is famous for its soul-satisfying Italian dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, and offers an extensive selection of Italian wines and cocktails.



New York is a city of immigrants, and the dishes here seem to take inspiration from immigrants. The city is dotted with countless eateries, among them restaurants that have mastered the art of preparing Italian cuisine.

Not every restaurant does Italian right, but these are the best Italian restaurants in New York for visitors and locals alike.

10 L’Artusi: Savor Sweet Ricotta-Filled Tortelli In The West Village

228 West 10th Street, New York, NY 10014
Photo by David Groves on Unsplash

New York, United States

L’Artusi is a go-to destination for locals and travelers looking to experience modern Italian cuisine in a comfortable setting. The restaurant opened its doors in December 2008 and has since won the respect of chefs and restaurateurs.

At the heart of bustling Manhattan, this casual dining restaurant offers a welcoming eating space reminiscent of Italian Trattorias. The typical menu features handmade pasta, crudo, and a handful of meat and fish. There is also an extensive selection of wines and cocktails.

  • Address:
    228 West 10th Street, New York, NY 10014

L’Artusi can host parties of up to 110 in the wine room; make a reservation in advance.

9 Via Carota: Crunch Into Wood-Grilled Octopus At This Rustic Trattoria Gem

View of NYC through chain link fence at sunset
Photo by Matteo Catanese on Unsplash

View of NYC through chain link fence at sunset

Via Carota is a charming eatery famous for its rustic furnishing and, of course, delicious Italian dishes. Although it is not the most decorated, guests will be delighted by the restaurant’s interior, which is adorned with dark wood, brick walls, and vintage furniture, creating a calming eating space.

Over the years, Via Carota has continued to showcase its commitment to honoring old-world Italian roots, lifestyle, and food. Ms. Sodi and Ms. William pride themselves in preparing dishes that pay homage to Italy’s rich culinary traditions.

Should visitors be seeking a space to have a romantic dinner, Via Carota has secluded areas where travelers can enjoy authentic Italian flavors as they make memories with their partners.

  • Address:
    51 Grove St, New York, NY 10014

  • Contact:
    (212) 255-1962

8 Babbo: Feast On Soul-Satisfying Spaghetti Carbonara At Mario Batali’s Lively Eatery

Several cars in Lower East Side, Manhattan, NYC
Photo by Aleks Marinkovic on Unsplash

Several cars in Lower East Side, Manhattan, NYC

Babbo was established in 1998, and it has since joined the ranks as one of the best Italian restaurants in New York. The restaurant claims to make Italian food the way an Italian would.

The menu incorporates fresh, high-quality ingredients from local farms and markets to create authentic flavor. Guests can expect simple yet delicious cuisine.

Like most Italian eateries, Babbo offers an extensive selection of Italian wines and cocktails to complement their dishes.

  • Address:
    110 Waverly PL., New York, NY 10011

  • Make sure to taste the signature grilled octopus and beef cheek ravioli.

7 IL Buco: Journey Through Northern Italy With Risotto Bathed In Barolo Wine At This Noho Treasure.

NYC view from Hoboken
Photo by Jimmy Woo on Unsplash

View of New York City from Hoboken, New Jersey

Housed in a former antique shop in the historic NoHo neighborhood, Il Buco is one of the most beloved Italian restaurants. For over 29 years, it has earned a reputation for its unique approach to Italian dishes.

From housemade pizzas with perfectly blistered crusts to aged prosciutto and house-cured salumi, Il Buco has shown commitment to preserving Italian cooking traditions. There are private dining spaces suited for events and dinners, while the wine cellar is a magical setting for any occasion.

  • Address:
    4 East 2nd Street, New York, NY 10003

  • Contact:
    (917) 946-3085

6 Lupa: Comfort Yourself With Simple, Delicious Cacio E Pepe And Gricia Pastas

Empire State Building, NYC
Photo by Phil Hauser on Unsplash

An aerial view of Empire State Building, NYC

Lupa Restaurant is where the aromas of Italy invite travelers to enjoy a memorable culinary journey. It is a casual restaurant whose goal is to create dishes as traditionally Italian as possible.

The restaurant’s interior is welcoming, with rustic chandeliers and decor that sets the stage for a convivial dining atmosphere. Their commitment results in an Italian menu with a New York balance, with bavette cacio e Pepe, bucatini all’Amatriciana, saltimbocca alla Romana, and octopus being its signature dishes.

Overall, Lupa is a fun New York downtown trattoria that promises to whisk visitors away on a voyage of culinary delight. Their approach to wine and liquor is also one of the best.

  • Address:
    170 Thompson Street, New York, NY 10012

  • Contact:
    (212) 982-5089

5 Rezdôra: Hearty Tuscan Wild Boar Ragù Coats Chewy Tagliatelle And Mushrooms At This Modern Escape

An aerial sunset view of Manhattan Uptown, New York City, USA
Photo by Jan Folwarczny on Unsplash

An aerial sunset view of Manhattan Uptown, New York City, USA

Nestled in the heart of the Flatiron District, Rezdôra is a celebrated Italian restaurant that mainly serves its guests Emilia-Romagna cuisine. The restaurant’s menu is centered around house pasta, some of which are hand-made using traditional techniques, but travelers can also enjoy traditionally prepared meat, fish, and local vegetables.

Northern Italian wines complement the dishes.

The restaurant has a stylish yet inviting interior that reflects the spirit of old-school Italian trattorias and is one of the best Italian restaurants in New York.

  • Address:
    27 East 20th Street, New York, NY 10003

  • Contact:
    (646) 692-9090

4 I Sodi: Get Fresh Burrata Cheese And Juicy Tomatoes At This Seasonal West Village Spot

Bleecker Street Greenwich Village NYC
Photo by Josh Appel on Unsplash

View of Bleecker Street, Greenwich Village, NYC

I Sodi is a culinary haven hidden in the heart of Manhattan’s West Village and is well-known for its authentic Tuscan cuisine and charming, intimate atmosphere.

Rita opened the restaurant to appreciate her mother’s simple cooking. Over the years, I Sodi has earned a reputation for serving classic Italian dishes, including handmade pasta. Interestingly, the focus on traditional Tuscan flavors extends to a selection of wines to complement their delicious offerings.

What makes I Sodi stand out is the genuine hospitality and personalized service that leaves guests with cherished memories of an Italian dining experience.

  • Address:
    314 Bleecker Street, New York, NY 10014

  • Contact:
    (212) 414. 5774

3 Al Di Là Trattoria: Get Some Smoky Eggplant Pasta Alla Norma In Cozy Brooklyn

Entrance in restaurant with decorations
Photo by Rachel Claire on Pexels

Al Di Là Trattoria is a family-owned restaurant and has been a favorite for locals in Park Slope and travelers since 1998. This Brooklyn-based restaurant offers traditional Italian cuisine in a warm and inviting environment.

The most coveted dishes Al Di Là Trattoria serves are homemade pasta and wood-fired pizzas, but there is a variety of other classic Italian dishes. Travelers can find tagliatelle with ragu, pappardelle with wild boar ragu, rabbit stew, baked clams, spaghetti with meatballs, and roast chicken.

Visitors will also enjoy their assortment of cocktails and wines sourced from reputable brands.

  • Address:
    248 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

  • Contact:
    (718) 783-4565

2 Fausto: Southern Italian Flavors Shine Through Spicy Braised Octopus In An East Village Enclave

Brooklyn, New York City

Brooklyn, New York City

Fausto is an enchanting restaurant that showcases an artful blend of Italian and Mediterranean flavors. It draws its inspiration from its surroundings, and with its contemporary approach to classic Italian cuisine, Fausto serves a variety of authentic dishes prepared using the finest seasonal ingredients from local farms.

From the silky Tajarin with black truffle butter to satisfying bucatini all’Amatriciana, Fausto’s kitchen showcases modern variations on traditional housemade pasta and sauces.

Chef Erin Shambura’s cooking style helps preserve the deep flavors, and Joe Campanale will help travelers pick an equally exceptional wine to complement their meal.

  • Address:
    348 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

  • Contact:
    (917) 909-1427

1 Song E Napule: Get Blistered Lemon Spaghetti And Charred Margherita Pizzas At This Bustling Neapolitan Pizzeria

Times Square, NYC, USA
Photo by Alex Haney on Unsplash

Times Square, NYC, USA

Located in the heart of West Village, Song E Napule is a high-end restaurant that pays homage to the vibrant culinary heritage of the southern Italian city. The restaurant opened its doors in January 2015 and has since served delicacies made from local, seasonal ingredients.

Song E Napule’s menu focuses on classic dishes that have been passed down through generations, mainly authentic Neapolitan pizza.

  • Address:
    146 West Houston Street, New York, NY 10012

  • Contact:
    (212) 533-1242

Though these are some of the best Italian restaurants in New York, there’s always something new to discover on the dining scene in NYC. Keep those taste buds ready while exploring the city!

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *